Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Reel Bar - Put-In-Bay, OH
Welcome to the vibrant Reel Bar, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Put-In-Bay, OH. With its inviting atmosphere overlooking the scenic landscape, this establishment has quickly earned a stellar reputation among both locals and tourists. Located at 461 Catawba Ave, the Reel Bar is not just a place to eat but an experience that celebrates the spirit of island life.
The menu showcases a delightful array of choices, ensuring that there is something for everyone. Guests rave about the Fire-In-The-Hole burger, highlighted by customer Daniel Smith as the top burger on the island. Meanwhile, the Sweet Bourbon and Black Bean burgers, along with the classic kids Cheeseburger, ensure every palate is satisfied. It’s clear from the glowing reviews that the quality of food is consistently high and made with care.
Food lover Cullen McEaneney notes that the prices are reasonable for the quality and setting, making it a top choice for families and friends alike. The laid-back island vibe complements the delicious dishes, allowing you to savor your meal while soaking in the relaxed surroundings.
For seafood enthusiasts, Nicole Dierolf highlights that the Reel Bar caters to diverse tastes, offering unique seafood dishes that cater to those who enjoy the ocean's bounty. This accessibility makes it a perfect stop for couples or families with varied preferences, ensuring everyone walks away satisfied.
Furthermore, the friendly and knowledgeable staff embody the warm hospitality that complements your dining experience. K. Gunny emphasizes the generous portions, noting the loaded nachos and scrumptious burgers—dishes that promise to delight and fill you to the brim!
Reel Bar is more than a restaurant; it is a hub for fun and relaxation, especially during summer events. Halle's review perfectly encapsulates the lively atmosphere, with the outdoor porch providing an ideal spot for enjoying vibrant drinks or delicious meals while watching the world go by.
So, whether you're seeking a lively lunch spot, a cozy dinner, or simply a drink to enjoy with friends, Reel Bar is sure to deliver an unforgettable dining experience. Stop by and indulge in the culinary delights, each bite a testament to the island’s charm and the dedication of its chefs. You won’t want to miss out on this beloved Put-In-Bay destination!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ 10/10 Best burgers in the island. Personally the best choice is the Fire-In-The-Hole burger but we did try the Sweet Bourbon, Black Bean and the kids Cheeseburger. The staff are friendly and professional with knowledge of the menu. The place is worth a visit again and again. Definitely, I got my money's worth. ”
“ The food totally rules, and not terribly expensive. For the atmosphere and the general environment of the area it was perfect. Would definitely eat here again next time I’m on the island. Lots of choices to eat, and all of it sounded good, but I can only eat so much. My family and friends loved their meals, too, though, so it’s not just my opinion, but theirs too! ”
“ An island feel with amazing food. I love seafood and hubby does not. This place had something on the menu for both of us. Amazing menu. Great bar are. Open Island feel and not that dark atmosphere that some of the places have. Highly recommend this place to stop for lunch or dinner while on ypur island adventure ”
“ Fantastic place for lunch, dinner, drinks, everything. The bartender is amazing, and the food is unique and delicious. They are interactive during the summer with different events, and always have really great service. Good atmosphere, nice porch outside and fun drinks if you stop up in September, too. We always stop here at least once when visiting the island and you should too . Grouper sandwiches and perch tacos etc etc ”
“ YUM! Definitely stop in to Reel Bar! You won't regret it! We are so glad we stopped and tried it! The nachos were loaded... Delicious! & The burger was great! Don't skip this place up if you get the chance to visit Put in Bay! ... ”
“ Got good reviews from a friend so we stopped to check it out for ourselves. Atmosphere was great and the staff was friendly,loved the open air feel. First, start with one of theif fantastic and creative drinks. Possible the best drink menu on the island. Our food was great; Dishes were served hot and seasoned just right. Only wish we had time to visit for breakfast! Next time. ”
“ Husband had the Philly cheesesteak and I had the hot honey chicken sandwich. Both were delicious and the fries were fabulous!!! ”
“ Food was awesome. We had the sweet bourbon burger, added tomatoe lettuce onion and pickle on it. and lobster rolls. The fries were really good as well. Atmosphere was mellow and the waitresses were friendly. ”